HVAC Choices

[HersheyHound]

Purchased 1,400 SF ranch in PA. House has baseboard electric heat (several not working), working A/C with duct work in ceiling, open fireplace. There is no access to natural gas. Looking at options to replace heating (and a/c ?) The a/c is Trane and approximately 12 years old. This is a rental unit, so not looking to go for high end - just middle of the road and dependable. Also not interested in having a working wood fireplace - tenants tend to be very messy!

Heat pump?
propane gas heat?
propane gas fireplace insert for extra heat?

[FatimaandAhmed]

Given the details you've shared, a heat pump might be a fantastic option for replacing both your heating and A/C systems. Heat pumps are efficient and versatile, providing both heating and cooling in one unit. They generally work well in moderate climates like Pennsylvania’s and can save you from having to manage separate systems for heating and cooling. Although the initial cost can be higher, it might be a worthwhile investment for a rental property due to their efficiency and lower long-term operational costs.

If you’re not ready to replace the A/C just yet, another route is installing a propane gas furnace for heating while keeping your existing A/C. Propane heating systems are efficient and can provide reliable warmth, though you’ll need to manage a propane tank and refilling. For an additional touch, you might consider a propane gas fireplace insert. This could offer extra warmth and a cozy atmosphere in common areas like the living room, though it won’t replace the need for a primary heating source.

It’s a good idea to consult with local HVAC professionals who can assess your home’s specifics and provide tailored recommendations and quotes. They’ll help you understand the long-term costs associated with each option, considering fuel or electricity prices and maintenance needs. Balancing upfront costs with reliability and tenant comfort will be key to making the best choice for your rental unit.